Here is the calendar for the remaining AGMs during the main 2024 AGM season which runs until Friday, November 29. Main season AGMs that have already been held since AGL kicked things off on September 25 are listed at the bottom and here is a list of all AGMs attended so far in calendar 2024.
Below is the text of the written questions submitted at the two and a half hour Mineral Resources hybrid AGM held in Perth on November 21, 2024. See notice of meeting. There was a whopping 70% rem strike which wasn't disclosed with the formal addresses.
This list tracks almost 200 companies capitalised at more than $30 million which failed to deliver full online AGM participation (questions and voting) after the COVID restrictions were lifted. Quite a few of them are controlled by scrutiny-averse Rich Listers.
Below is a bucket list of interesting ASX listed companies where am yet to attend their AGM but would like to in the future. Many of them are dinosaurs which ban online voting and questions at their physical only AGMs.
Here are some standard AGM questions likely to be asked at 2024 AGMs for chairs wishing to prepare in advance. Further preparation can be done looking through the text of the exchanges at the 109 AGMs attended in calendar 2023 or these 130 meetings in 2022.
Here is a list of more than 25 companies which (often after a direct request) agreed to provide poll results and/or proxy votes by both shares and shareholders, thereby providing an insight into retail shareholder sentiment and participation numbers. This is the way forward to stimulate greater retail shareholder participation in voting which has crashed to below 3%. In terms of which share registry provider is delivering, Link has done 15, followed by Computershare with 8 and Boardroom with 5.
Here is a rapidly growing list of more than 50 companies which have adopted the best practice of lodging the proxy position with the ASX along with the formal addresses before the AGM/EGM commences. It doesn't cruel debate at the AGM because it doesn't have to be announced to the AGM before the debate commences, if that's what chairs are worried about. Otherwise, it allows for a fully informed debate on any big protest votes whilst providing more timely data to the market and all stakeholders, including institutional investors and proxy advisers. Sometimes this data can be market sensitive, so arguably directors should release it as soon as possible after the proxy voting deadline closes 48 hours before the meeting.
Below is a list of the 140 AGMs participated in so far in calendar 2024. Thanks to the ease of online access, there was a record 70 in 2021 and then 130 in 2022 followed by 109 in 2023. This lifted the overall tally since 1998 to 940 and we're aiming to crack 1000 before May 31 next year.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the WAM Research hybrid AGM held on November 21 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 8 written questions submitted at the 90 minute Accent Group hybrid AGM held on November 21 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 9 written questions submitted at the 80 minute Peninsular Energy hybrid AGM held in Perth on November 21 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There was a CEO preso that started at the 80 minute mark.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the GOZ hybrid AGM held on November 21 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 1 hour Auswide Bank hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on November 18, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the Resimac virtual AGM held on November 18, 2024.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 30 minute 2024 LGI hybrid AGM held on November 20 in Brisbane, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Proxies disclosed early in slide pack and no protest votes. Was only shareholder asking questions at company capitalised at $278m.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 65 minute Generation Development Group (formerly AusDoc) hybrid AGM held on November 19, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2024 Bluescope hybrid AGM held on November 19 2024. Credit to them, they delivered the extra voting data.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the Sonic Healthcare hybrid AGM held on November 19 2024.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the Impedimed hybrid AGM held on November 19 2024.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 70 minute KMD Brands hybrid AGM held in Auckland on November 19, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the Monadelphous hybrid AGM held on November 19, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the farcical De Grey Mining hybrid AGM held on November 19 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early proxies and some modest protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 75 minute Seek hybrid AGM held on November 19, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early proxies or extra voting data and solid rem protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Pact Group hybrid AGM and EGM held on November 14 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the written questions submitted at the Cettire hybrid AGM held on November 14 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the Guzman Y Gomez hybrid AGM held on November 14 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 34 minute Senetas hybrid AGM held on November 15 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Two of the questions were ignored. Biggest protest 8% against CEO's options grant.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 132 minute Lendlease hybrid AGM held on November 24 2024. No early disclosure of the proxies in the formal addresses or extra data in these poll results.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 70 minute Sandfire Resources hybrid AGM held on November 15 2024 via Zoom, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early disclosure of the proxies and copped a whopping 54% second rem strike but minimal support for the spill.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the 45 minute Fonterra hybrid AGM held on November 18 2024. Two were completed ignored and the other two were butchered as detailed below so a very disappointing effort by question wrangler Jackie.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the Lifestyle Communities hybrid AGM held on November 12 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There was no early disclosure of the proxies and biggest protest vote was 7% against chair David Blight.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the marathon Coles hybrid AGM held on November 12 2024. There was no early disclosure of the proxies and the final results showed 39% support for the salmon farming shareholder resolution.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the Platinum Asset Management hybrid AGM held on November 12 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There was no early disclosure of proxies unlike in 2023 and the final poll showed a massive 73% second strike and the defeat of the CEO's LTI grant because founder Kerr Neilson voted his circa 20% against on the floor. See remarkable proxies and poll results.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 95 minute Nanosonics hybrid AGM held on November 12 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were commendably disclosed early with the formals and there were no protest votes. The meeting was prematurely closed with 9 un-asked online questions, 2 of which were mine.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 100 minute Contact Energy hybrid AGM held on November 13 2024 in Auckland, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 50 minute Nuix hybrid AGM held on November 13, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions submitted at the Endeavour Group hybrid AGM held on November 13 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 53 minute Tyro hybrid AGM held on November 13, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Was the sole questioner, beside 1 other single online question.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 83 minute Sky Network Television hybrid AGM held in Auckland on November 14 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the Goodman Group hybrid AGM held on November 14 2024, where the proxies showed a 35% rem strike.
Below is the text of the single audit question submitted at the 73 minute Flight Centre hybrid AGM held on November 14, 2024. The proxies were disclosed early and they delivered extra voting data with no protests so well done.
This list tracks when companies first agreed to publish a full transcript of their AGM, an issue we have been pushing for the past couple of years.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 110 minute 2024 IGO hybrid AGM held on November 6, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed early with the formals.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 115 minute Coast Entertainment hybrid AGM held on November 6, 2024 plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early disclosure of the proxies with these formal addresses and biggest protest 20% against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the 3 hour Sky City Entertainment hybrid AGM held at its Auckland casino on October 31, 2024, along with a summary of the answers and some videos via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 8 written questions submitted at the two hour Steadfast hybrid AGM held in Sydney on November 1. The proxies were disclosed early with these formal addresses and the biggest protest was 15% against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Spark NZ hybrid AGM held in Auckland on November 1, plus a summary of the answer and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 2 written questions submitted at the 42 minute 2024 Cedar Woods hybrid AGM held on November 6. The proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses and there were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 AJ Lucas hybrid AGM held on November 7, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Don't know what responses were provided as still waiting for the AGM archive here.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Clearvue hybrid AGM held on November 7, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 45 minute Navigator hybrid AGM held on October 31, 2024 plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no material protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2 hour 2024 Bega Group hybrid AGM held on October 30, plus a summary of the exchanges below. The proxies weren't disclosed early and biggest protest was 14% against rem report.
Below is the text of the 2 written questions submitted at the 50 minute JB Hi Fi hybrid AGM held on October 31, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early disclosure of the proxies with these formals and disappointing they didn't follow the agenda.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the lively 83 minute Fleetwood hybrid AGM held on October 30 in Sydney, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed early with the formals and no extra data in these voting results.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions submitted at the 2024 Woolworths hybrid AGM held on October 31, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxy votes were withheld until after the debate on each item. There was a 19% protest against Maxine Brenner and 30% support for the first of two contingent hostile shareholder resolutions on salmon farming practices.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions submitted at the 2024 Wesfarmers hybrid AGM held on October 31, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early disclosure of the proxies with these formal addresses and no extra voting data in these poll results.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the Nine hybrid AGM held on November 7, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Came good with early proxy disclosure and finished with a 37% rem strike and 17% against chair Catherine West.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the Jumbo Interactive hybrid AGM held on November 8, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early proxy disclosure and no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 8 written questions submitted at the Bisalloy Steel virtual AGM held on November 8, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. In addition to the formal addresses, there was also this strange myth-busting session from the CEO after the formal business had been dealt with. Multiple protest votes.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 32 minute Lindsay Australia hybrid AGM in Brisbane on November 8, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Confusing half-baked proxy disclosure in the formals and circa 10% rem protest with no percentages included in announcement.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the Domain hybrid AGM held on November 6, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early proxy disclosure and only protest 13.3% against CEO's LTI grant.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 90 minute 2024 Domino's hybrid AGM held on November 6. There was a 14% protest against rem and 9% against director Lynda O'Grady.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 20 minute Wotso Property hybrid AGM held on November 8, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed the night before with the chair address and there were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 105 minute Bendigo Bank hybrid AGM held on November 7 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed early and the biggest protest vote was 19.4% against rem report.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 65 minute 2024 Data#3 hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on October 30, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed with the formals, no extra poll data and biggest protest 12% against director Mark Esler.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 130 minute Qantas hybrid AGM held in Hobart on October 25, 2024, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Only question 4 on the chairman's lounge was censored. The proxies weren't disclosed early with the formal addresses but they did provide transparency in these poll results.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Heartland Group hybrid AGM held on October 30.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 55 minute 2024 Civmec hybrid AGM held on October 30 in Singapore, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Ansell hybrid AGM held on October 29. No early disclosure of the proxies or protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Trajan virtual AGM held on October 29.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 McMillan Shakespeare hybrid AGM held at 10am on October 25.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2 hour 2024 ASX Group hybrid AGM held on October 28, along with a summary of the answers. Proxies weren't disclosed with the formals but excellent transparency with these voting results.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 CSL hybrid AGM held on October 29 at the RACV Club in Melbourne. Unfortunately, 4 of these questions were censored even though the entire meeting was wrapped up in less than 2 hours. There was no early disclosure of the proxies and they copped both a rem strike and a major protest against the CEO's LTI, which was hardly discussed because they didn't follow the agenda.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 45 minute MacMahon Holdings hybrid AGM held in Perth on October 29, 2024. Sadly three of them were censored, which was weird given there were no floor questions and only 2 other online questions from a Tony Greco. At least the proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 95 minute Cochlear hybrid AGM held in Sydney on October 25, 2024. No early disclosure of the proxies or material protest votes.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2024 Pinnacle Investment Management hybrid AGM held at 9am on October 25. See notice of meeting and link to Computershare platform. These 91 slides including the proxies were released at 6pm the night before the meeting and this 6 page address from the CEO at 8.21am on the morning of the meeting.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Cleanaway hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on October 24.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 105 minute South32 hybrid AGM held on October 24, 2024 plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed early and there were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions submitted at the 2024 Chorus hybrid AGM held on October 24.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 hybrid AGM held on October 25.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2024 Super Retail hybrid AGM held on October 24, along with a summary of the answers and some video via Twitter. There was no early disclosure of the proxies in the formals and the biggest protest was 17% against the CEO's LTI grant.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 Codan hybrid AGM held on October 23. There was no early disclosure of the proxies and no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Mystate hybrid AGM held on October 23. Biggest protest 17% against rem.
Below is the text of 1 of the 3 written questions submitted at the 2024 Challenger hybrid AGM held on October 23. Am waiting for the webcast archive to be published here to find out what happened. There was no early disclosure of the proxies with the formal addresses and the results showed no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Fletcher Building hybrid AGM held on October 23.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 National Storage hybrid AGM held on October 23, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Two were ignored, the proxies weren't disclosed early and the biggest protest vote was 9% against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 8 written questions submitted at the 2024 Amotiv hybrid AGM held on October 21, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs. The italicised bits weren't read out, the proxies weren't disclosed early and they refused to provide additional voting outcome data. There were modest protests of 13% John Pollaers and the 17.64% against the CEO's LTI grant.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 90 minute 2024 Stockland hybrid AGM held on October 21. No early disclosure of proxies with formal addresses and biggest protest vote 28% against director Melinda Conrad.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 30 minute Atturra Software virtual AGM held on October 21, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. No early disclosure of proxies and only protest 12% against extra 10% of placement capacity.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 Audinate hybrid AGM held on October 22. Biggest protest vote 6.1% against director John Dyson.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 90 minute Transurban hybrid AGM held on October 22, 2024, plus a brief summary of the answers. The proxies weren't disclosed early with the formal addresses and the debate was handled as one job lot, disappointingly. No major protest votes or extra voting transparency.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 90 minute Suncorp hybrid AGM held on October 22, 2024, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses and they delivered on extra transparency these voting results.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 35 minute SG Fleet virtual AGM held on October 22, 2024 plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies weren't disclosed with these formal addresses and there were 10% protest votes against both directors up for election.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2024 Bapcor hybrid AGM held on October 16 at Melbourne Airport. There was no early disclosure of the proxies. See big rem protest votes.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 AIA International hybrid AGM held at Eden Park on October 17, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 3.5 hour 2024 Perpetual hybrid AGM held in Sydney on October 17. The proxies were disclosed with the formal addresses and biggest protest vote was 88% against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 75 minute 2024 EVT hybrid AGM held on October 18, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Proxies were disclosed early and there was a rem strike with 34% against.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 40 minute 2024 AFG hybrid AGM held in Perth on October 18, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed early, including with shareholder voting data, which was removed from the final poll results.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 95 minute 2024 hybrid AGM held in Wellington on October 15, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses. There were no material protest votes, largely because there was only 1 item of business, a director election resolution.
Examples of written AGM questions butchered by questions wrangler.
Best practice is for companies to do a "key dates" announcement each year spelling out the timetable for shareholders in the following 12 months. Here are some good examples.
Here is the full a list of 849 public company AGMs or EGMs where Stephen Mayne has asked questions as a shareholder or proxy since it all began for The Daily Telegraph way back in October 1998, complete with links to stories written at the time, AGM webcasts, transcripts and any relevant media coverage. Thanks to online AGMs after COVID, there was 30 AGMs in 2020, a record 70 in 2021 and then 130 in 2022 followed by 109 in 2023 and this many so far in 2024.
Below is the calendar for interesting AGMs and EGMs which took place before the main 2024 AGM season which started in late September. This will help guide planning in 2025.
Below is a list of the 109 AGMs participated in during calendar 2023. Thanks to the ease of online access, there was a record 70 in 2021 and then 130 in 2022. This lifted the overall tally since 1998 above 700.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the PSC Insurance hybrid scheme meeting held on September 26, 2024, to approve a $2.23 billion private equity takeover. Despite there being no other questions, only the first one was dealt with on the day but I couldn't hear the answer properly due to microphone issues. CEO Tony Robinson later called to apologise and provided the written answers published below. The formal addresses were only released after the meeting with the poll results and there were no protest votes.
Below is a list of the AGMs or EGMs where Stephen Mayne, or his proxy, asked questions in 2022. After a record 70 last year, we almost doubled that to 130 in 2022 given the ease of access provided by online or hybrid AGMs. This lifted the overall tally since 1998 above 670.
This list tracks the deluge of last day of the mini-season AGMs held on May 31, 2024.
This list tracks the disorganised companies which held their AGMs on Thursday, November 30, 2023, the last possible day under the law and the ASX listing rules for companies with a June 30 balance date. 30 had communicated with the ASX before the 10am opening of trade, 52 by 11am, 71 by 1pm and 40 which landed after 6pm. There were 3 more (Argenica, Korab Resources and Peppermint Innovations) who fessed up on December 1, hence the increase from 165 to 168.
This list looks at retail shareholder turn out rates on takeovers or transactions which are delivered by a scheme of arrangement. These normally require 75% of votes in favour and 50% of shareholders who choose to vote.
This list tracks some of the biggest against votes of more than 25% on remuneration reports since the non-binding vote was introduced in 2005, particularly focusing on so-called "strikes" after the 2 strikes regime was introduced in July 2011.
This list tracks companies which have a history of adopting best practice in AGM transparency, both in how the AGM is delivered to maximise use of technology and participation and how comprehensive their online archive of AGM activity is.
Below is a shame file of current listed companies which are refusing to publish a transcript or archived copy of their 2022 AGM webcast.
When companies with September 30 balance dates hold their AGMs.
Quite a few companies have tried and failed to amend their constitutions to allow for fully virtual AGMs with no physical component. Here is a list of companies which did or will run fully virtual AGMs in 2022.
This list tracks ASX listed companies with a market cap exceeding $100m which rejected live online AGM questions in 2022.
This list tracks companies which send physical annual reports during the main 2022 AGM season.
Here is a list of smaller companies offering hybrid AGMs in 2022, putting to shame this list of companies capitalised at more than $100 million which didn't allow any online voting or questions during their physical meetings.
This list tracks the 2023 AGM mini-season for public companies with December 31 balance dates, which are of interest in terms of potentially attending. And here is a list of the record 130 AGMs attended in 2022.
Directors are increasingly agreeing to have a non-binding "say on climate" vote in order to fend off shareholder resolutions. This list tracks the history of Australian "say on climate" votes.
Below are the details of the record 70 online AGMs that Stephen Mayne asked questions at in 2021, thanks to the benefit of virtual AGMs.
Below is a collection of transcripts of our questions and responses about gender diversity on Australian public company boards.
Women only represent 10% of directors on major public company boards in Australia. This is a disgrace and here are the audio files, links and transcripts where we've raised the issue.
This list tracks attempts to amend constitutions to allow for virtual only AGMs, many of which have been withdrawn or defeated by shareholders. See this Crikey piece explaining how corporates just refuse to accept the message.
Back when The Mayne Report had staff (ie 2007 until 2010), we were emailing companies asking them to send through transcripts from past AGMs which produced the following up until the end of 2010.
This list tracks the 2020 AGM mini-season during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Below is a package of some of favourite AGM audio highlights from the period 2007 until 2010.
Amidst the biggest deluge of capital raisings in Australian corporate history, we have been raising serious questions about the fairness of the system at AGMs as follows. Click on the links below.
Below is a compilation of audio files from various AGMs over the years where auditors have been asked to comment on the accounts.
Here are some interesting AGM exchanges from public company AGMS.
This list looks at companies which put out an ASX announcement clarifying an aspect of their remuneration arrangements shortly before an AGM, usually at the prompting of proxy advisers or major institutional investors.
Here is the text of 7 written questions lodged and asked asked at the 2024 APM Human Services virtual scheme meetings held on September 18 to approve the $1.33 billion Madison Dearborn takeover. No video was provided and no other shareholder asked any questions at either of the two meetings.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 3 hour and 20 minute 2024 Telstra hybrid AGM held on October 15. The proxies weren't disclosed early with the formal addresses and there was a 15% protest vote on 2 rem items.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions submitted at the 1 hour and 51 minute 2024 Genesis Energy hybrid AGM held in Wellington on October 15 before we hit the overall character limit imposed through the Computershare platform. No protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 1 hour and 45 minute 2024 Region Group hybrid AGM held on October 15, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no material protest votes.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions submitted at the 32 minute 2024 Reject Shop virtual AGM held on October 16, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 2 written questions submitted at the 2024 CBA hybrid AGM held on October 16 in Adelaide, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The meeting lasted 2 hours and 27 minutes and there were no material protest votes.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 AUI hybrid AGM held on October 16, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no material protests and excellent transparency in the voting results.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 97 minute 2024 Aurizon Holdings hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on October 10, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The only protest votes were against the two directors up for election.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2024 AGL hybrid AGM held in Melbourne on September 25. Kudos to the question wrangler for reading them all out in full, with excellent intonation. There were no protest votes. Below is a summary of the responses and some video grabs of the exchanges. Also, see webcast archive and full transcript.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 REA Group virtual AGM held at 9am on October 9, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The only material protest at the 45 minute meeting was 7.3% against chair Hamish McLennan.
Here is a the text of the 6 written question lodged at the 2024 Metcash hybrid AGM held in Sydney on September 13. Most were edited down and below is a summary of the answers provided with links to video grabs via Twitter. The meeting lasted about 90 minutes with 2 questioners in the room (including ASA) and two of us online. There were modest rem protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 multi-faceted written questions asked at the 2024 Macquarie Group hybrid AGM held on July 24, along with a summary of the answers and video grabs via Twitter. Commendably, they were read out in full with no censorship. No material protest votes at the 3 hour meeting but the board received quit a grilling on a range of issues from the floor, spanning climate, bank victims, buy backs, pay, regulatory sanctions and even Gaza.
Here is the text of the 5 questions lodged at the 2024 Probiotec hybrid scheme meeting held on May 29.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Brazilian Rare Earths virtual AGM held in Sydney at 9am on May 31.
Below are the 6 written questions lodged at the 2024 OFX hybrid AGM, held in Sydney and via Zoom on August 1. Gun shareholder activist Charlie Kingston gave them plenty of stick in the room. My written questions were butchered a bit by the chair and CEO but answers were generally good and below is a summary of how it rolled out. There were no protest votes and just awaiting the webcast archive.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Alumina scheme meeting on July 18 which approved the takeover by Alcoa. Proxies weren't disclosed with the formal addresses but there were no material protest votes at the 45 minute meeting which sailed through with support from 99.77% of voted stock in favour and 87.5% of the voting shareholders (1,598 for and 227 against out of circa 52,000).
Here is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 blank Far Ltd virtual AGM held on May 31, along with a summary of the answers and some audio grabs via Twitter. The meeting was all over in 20 minutes with no other shareholder participation.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Bluebet EGM to approve the BETR merger held on May 30, along with a summary of the answers. The meeting was done in 15 minutes and I was the only shareholder asking questions. There were no protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Yancoal hybrid AGM held on May 30, plus a summary of the answer and some audio files via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Neuren Pharmaceuticals hybrid AGM held on May 28. There were no protest votes but no rem items. See webcast of 85 minute meeting which was produced after a request.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2024 Tiger Realm Coal hybrid AGM held on May 28, along with a summary of the answers.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2024 Kina Bank virtual AGM held on May 29, along with a summary of the answers. Only 4 of them were asked, which is similar to what happened in 2023. I was the only questioner at the 30 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the Task Ltd scheme meeting to approve a $310m takeover by US firm PAR Technology on July 8, 2024.scheme meeting. I was the only questioner at the 22 minute meeting and below is a summary of the overly brief answers provided and some audio links by Twitter. There was a subsequent EGM at hour the scheme meeting approving two executive incentive grants - see text of 4 questions asked at that meeting.
Below is the text of the 4 written questions lodged at the Task Group virtual EGM held on July 8, 2024, shortly after the separate scheme meeting (see summary of questions asked) approving the $310m takeover by US-listed PAR Technology. I was the only questioner at this 12 minute meeting and below is a summary of the overly brief answers provided and some audio links by Twitter.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the QV Equities hybrid scheme meeting held on June 28, 2024, along with a summary of the answers when they weren't ignored. It is being taken over by bigger LIC rival WAM Leaders. Was approved by around 92% on both metrics.
Here is the text of the 6 questions lodged at the 2024 Brainchip hybrid AGM, held in Sydney on May 21. See interesting voting results showing only 14% of voted stock wanted a second strike board spill.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 Stanmore Resources hybrid AGM held on May 23, along with a summary of the answers. The proxies were disclosed early with these formal addresses.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 Pepper Money virtual AGM held on May 23, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses.
Here is the text of the 6 questions lodged at the 2024 Ventia Services virtual AGM held on May 23. The proxies were disclosed with the formal addresses.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 Karoon Gas hybrid AGM held on May 23, along with a summary of the answers. No early disclosure of the proxies. Meeting lasted 2 hours and 40 minutes. See video webcast of full meeting. Lots of protest votes including 28.7% against director Peter Turnbull, a 26% rem strike, 34.5% against the placement refresh and circa 20% against the fee rise for directors and the CEO's LTI grant.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 Eagers Automotive hybrid AGM held on May 22, along with a summary of the answers. There were no material protest votes at the 80 minute meeting and proxies were disclosed early with the formal addresses which contained a shock profit warning which drove the share price down 15% as the meeting commenced.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 29 Metals AGM, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Biggest protest vote 9.6% against rem report. Watch webcast of 77 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at 2024 Ampol hybrid AGM held on May 9 in Sydney, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Watch the webcast archive of the 75 minute meeting. There were no material protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 Atlas Arteria hybrid AGM held on May 16, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Biggest protest vote 4.95% against director fee rise. Watch webcast of 95 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at 2024 Briscoe Group hybrid AGM held on May 16 in Auckland, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged during the 2024 ARN Media hybrid AGM held on May 14, along with a summary of the answers. See webcast of 41 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 4 questions submitted at the 2024 Link Investment Services hybrid scheme held in Sydney on April 24, along with a summary of the answers and some video links via Twitter. The proxies were disclosed with the formal addresses and the deal was overwhelmingly approved by 99% of voted stock and 85% of voting shareholders (1,581 in favour and 281 against).
Below is the text of the 7 questions submitted at the 2024 Iluka Resources hybrid AGM held in Perth on May 7, along with a summary of the answers and some video links via Twitter. ASA rep John Campbell and I were the only two questioners and the only protest was 7.7% against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 6 questions submitted at the 2024 G8 Education hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on May 7, along with a summary of the answers and some video links via Twitter. The only protest vote was 10.7% against the rem report.
Here is the text of the 5 questions lodged at the 2024 Bell Financial Group virtual AGM held on April 19, plus a summary of the answers provided along with videos via Twitter. The meeting lasted 28 minute meeting. There was no early disclosure of the proxies in these formal addresses and the 3 board directors up for election weren't invited to speak. No material protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 QBE Insurance hybrid AGM held on May 10 in Sydney, plus a summary of the answers. There were no material protest votes at the 75 minute meeting and the proxies were displayed at the start of the meeting, rather than earlier with these formal addresses lodged with the ASX.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2024 Capral Aluminium virtual AGM held on May 8, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There were no material protest votes and there was only 1 other online question at the 50 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 6 Mayne family questions submitted at the 2024 Woodside Energy hybrid EGM held in Perth on April 24, with a summary of the answers and some video links via Twitter to be added in the near future. The proxies weren't disclosed with these formal addresses but the poll results showed a 16.6% vote against Richard Goyder's re-election and a whopping 58.36% against the climate action plan. Watch webcast of 4 hour meeting.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2024 AMP hybrid AGM held on April 12, along with a summary of the answers and some links to videos via Twitter. There were no material protest votes and the meeting lasted 2.5 hours with questions from about 20 different shareholders, including the fabulous activist fund manager, Fred Woollard.
Here is the text of the 3 written questions lodged at the 2024 Volpara Health Technologies scheme meeting held on April 12 in Wellington, where shareholders approved the nearly6 $300m sale of the business to a Korean company.
Here is the text of the 4 written questions asked at the Telix EGM held on April 5, 2024, along with videos of the exchanges via Twitter. All resolutions approving acquisition-related share issues were comfortably approved.
Here is a the text of the 8 written questions asked at the 2024 Scentre Group hybrid AGM held on April 4 in Sydney, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. There was a rem strike, plus a big protest against the CEO's LTI grant, along with some excellent pointed questions from Rich Lister turned AGM activist, David Kingston.
Was a hybrid AGM held in Sydney on December 15. Ran for the board. Didn't ask any questions but answered one via the phone line from Melbourne. Proxies were disclosed early. See poll results where achieved just 1.25% support. See webcast archive of 4 hour and 20 minute meeting and this wrap of all the action.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Objective Corp hybrid AGM held on November 29, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. Proxies were disclosed in these 51 formal slides and there were no major protest votes.
The following 9 written questions were lodged at the 2024 Aristocrat Leisure hybrid AGM held on February 22. Commendably, they were read out in full with no censorship at the 1 hour and 50 minute meeting. There was a 21% protest vote against the CEO's LTI grant which wasn't really properly discussed, partly because the proxies weren't disclosed with the formal addresses.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Integral Diagnostics hybrid AGM held on November 29, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. All resolutions supported by more than 90% of voted stock.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Wagners hybrid AGM held on November 28.
Here is the text of the 8 questions asked at the 2024 Technology One hybrid AGM held on February 21, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs via Twitter. The meeting lasted 80 minutes and the only protest votes were against the two directors seeking re-election.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 AMA Group hybrid AGM held on November 23, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs. These proxy votes were disclosed early with the formal addresses. See webcast of 49 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 8 written questions lodged at the 2023 Pointsbet hybrid AGM held on November 28, plus a summary of the answers and some video grabs. There were three circa 10% protest votes against a director and 2 rem resolutions.
Here is the text of the 3 questions asked at Allkem's scheme meeting held on December 19 2023 to approve the $10 billion Livent merger. The pre-AGM material revealed that 53% of the company's total capital had been proxy voted by 2081 holders and 89% of these shares were in favour but there was no disclosure on the headcount criteria, hence these questions.
Here is the text of the 5 questions lodged at the Boart Longyear scheme meeting held on February 21, 2024, to approve the takeover. All but one were censored and the meeting was done in less than 20 minutes.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2024 FleetPartners hybrid AGM held in Sydney on Thursday, January 25. I was the only of the 5,000 shareholders who asked questions. Voting results commendably showed outcome by shares and shareholders and there were no material protest votes with only 103 shareholders bothering to vote. Awaiting full archive of 1 hour webcast.
Here is a summary of the questions asked at the 2024 Nufarm hybrid AGM held at the company's Laverton headquarters on Thursday, February 1, 2024. There were no material protest votes at the 63 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 2023 Healius hybrid AGM held on November 28.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 2023 Qube hybrid AGM held on November 23, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs. No early proxy disclosure and there was a 15% vote against rem and 11% against rem chair Jacqui McArthur, who is also the last remaining female director. Watch the 80 minute webcast.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Karoon Energy hybrid AGM held on November 23. No sign of a webcast archive here.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Cash Converters virtual AGM held on November 23, plus a summary of the responses and some audio grabs.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Auswide Bank hybrid AGM held on November 24. Also, see these 10 questions from the 2022 AGM, which were handled far better than this year.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 2023 Starpharma hybrid AGM held on November 29. No early proxy disclosure and there was a 21% vote against rem and 28% against out-going CEO's LTI grant.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Ramelius Resources hybrid AGM held on November 23.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Wisetech virtual AGM held on November 24. No early disclosure of proxies and no material protest votes either, besides 5% against long-serving director Charles Gibbon. See webcast archive of 62 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 A2 Milk hybrid AGM held on November 16, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Ridley Corp hybrid AGM held on November 21. Proxies disclosed early with these formal addresses. Only protest vote 18% against CEO's retention grant. Waiting here for webcast archive to discover what answers were provided, especially to the first question after they refused to publish a web archive last year as well.
Below is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 2023 Bluescope Steel hybrid AGM held on November 21. See webcast of 98 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Australian Vintage hybrid AGM held on November 22. Proxies were disclosed early with the formals and there were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 2 written questions lodged at the 2023 Monadelphous hybrid AGM held on November 21. The lack of questions is partly informed by this account of the 2022 AGM. Was pleased they disclosed proxies early and there were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions lodged at the virtual K2 Asset Management AGM held on November 21, along with the text of answers emailed through by the company secretary later in the day. The Zoom exchanges and system was pretty wobbly. There were no protest votes.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2023 Flight Centre hybrid AGM held on November 15. Biggest protest was 7.3% against placement refresh. See webcast of 65 minute meeting plus this crack that founder CEO Graham Turner took at Transport Minister Catherine King over Qatar refusal. They also got with the program and disclosed voting outcome by shares and shareholders.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2023 Platinum Asset Management hybrid AGM held on November 15. See webcast of 107 minute meeting. Cranky founder Kerr Neilson voted his 21.4% stake at the meeting, delivering a huge 1st strike with 59% against the remuneration and almost defeating the CEO's LTI grant which only scraped through with 53% support.
Below is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 36 minute 2023 Capitol Health virtual AGM held on November 15, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs.
Below is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2023 Mt Gibson Iron hybrid AGM held on November 15, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs. Watch the 71 minute webcast. There was a 23.4% protest against long serving director Alan Jones.
Below is some of the action from the 2023 Myer hybrid AGM held on November 15. Watch webcast of 87 minute meeting. They deserve credit for announcing proxy position early by both shares and shareholders. The AGM results were also best practice along the same lines and only material protest vote was 18% against new director Gary Weiss for over-boarding.
Below is the text of the 3 written questions lodged at the 2023 News Corp virtual AGM held on November 16, along with a summary of the answers and some audio grabs. Also, see this photo of the log in page and read this Crikey piece about the ridiculous obstacles blocking shareholder participation. These AGM rules were ridiculously onerous. This AGM was also discussed with Alan Kohler on The Money Cafe podcast and Paddy Manning gave it a mention in The Saturday Paper. The voting results showed Lachlan Murdoch suffered the second biggest protest vote of the directors. Rupert sounded very frail handing over the Q&A to a management flunkey. This 19 minute webcast is only made available for 90 days after the meeting. Listen to Rupert's opening two minutes and how he closes.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2023 Goodman Group hybrid AGM held on November 14, 5 of which were asked. Below is a summary of the answers along with some video grabs. The proxies weren't disclosed early and there some moderate protest votes on rem (12.7%) and against chair Stephen Johns (7%). Watch 68 minute webcast.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions submitted at the 2023 Resimac hybrid AGM held on November 14. Five of them were dealt with and the only other question came from a former chairman about the sustainability of dividend payments.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2023 APM Human Services hybrid AGM held in Perth on November 10, plus as summary of the answers provide along with some video grabs.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 NIB AGM held in Sydney on November 10, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs. Only protest vote was 10% against re-election of director Anne Loveridge. Also watch this passionate re-election campaign speech by chair David Gordon. Watch webcast of 100 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 5 questions asked at the 1 hour 2023 KMD hybrid AGM held in Auckland on November 10, plus a summary of the answers below. Proxies were disclosed early with these formal addresses.
5 questions lodged at 2023 Jumbo Interactive hybrid AGM held on November 9.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Nine Entertainment AGM held on November 9. No material protest votes and see coverage in The Age.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions submitted at the 2023 Allkem hybrid AGM held on November 8. All of them were needlessly censored and cut back by the question wrangler. See video grabs and summaries of the answers below. There were big protest votes which should have been disclosed earlier. It was also bizarre that we rushed through formal business and then had lengthy addresses from the chair and CEO after the meeting had been formally closed. There were only 2 further questions after that.
6 written questions lodged at 2023 Ardent Leisure hybrid AGM held on November 8 on the Gold Coast. The biggest protest vote was 5% against over-worked chair Gary Weiss. Was an excellent 2 hour meeting thanks to the probing question in the room from David and Charlie Kingston.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the inaugural 2023 Redox AGM, which was a hybrid with the physical component held in Sydney. The proxies were disclosed early with no material protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2023 Cromwell hybrid AGM held on November 1.
A small number of written questions were lodged asked at the 2023 Polynovo hybrid AGM held on November 3 in Melbourne, coinciding with the Qantas AGM. I forgot to take a copy. They made an ASX announcement about this "edited version" of the AGM webcast and the only questions commence 80 minutes into proceedings.
5 questions asked at 2023 Megaport hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on November 1. No sign of webcast archive here.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions lodged at the 2023 Endeavour Group AGM held on October 31, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs of the exchanges.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions submitted at the 2023 Qantas hybrid AGM held on November 3. Only 5 were asked. See webcast of 2 hour and 29 minute meeting and these extraordinary voting results.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at the 2023 Southern Cross Austereo AGM held on October 27, which were read out in full. Questions were handled as one job lot but the answers were okay in the circumstances. See archive of 72 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions asked at the 2023 APA AGM held on October 26, along with a summary of the 3 answers and some video grabs. See webcast archive for 95 minute meeting. The biggest protest vote 25.7% against rem report.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 McMillan Shakespeare hybrid AGM held on October 27. Watch webcast archive of 1 hour meeting. No material protest votes.
Here is the text of the 4 written questions asked at the 2023 JB Hi Fi AGM held on October 26, along with a summary of the answers.
Here is the video record of the 3 written questions asked at the 2023 South32 hybrid AGM held on October 26. Watch video of 135 minute webcast. There were no material protest votes.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at the 2023 Carsales hybrid AGM held on October 26, along with a summary of the answers.
Here is the text of the 4 written questions asked at the 2023 Wesfarmers AGM held on October 27, along with a summary of the answers. Watch the full 2 hour 44 minute webcast archive.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at the 2023 Tabcorp hybrid AGM held on October 26, along with a summary of some of the answers and some video grabs.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at 2023 Ansell hybrid AGM held on October 24.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at the 2.5 hour 2023 Coles hybrid AGM held on November 3, two of which were ignored. There were double digit protest votes against all 3 rem resolutions but no strike.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Cleanaway hybrid AGM held on October 20.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 Macmahon Holdings hybrid AGM held on October 20. Watch the webcast archive, starting 37 minutes into proceedings.
Here is the text of the 7 questions asked at the 2023 EVT hybrid AGM held on October 20. The interesting debate lasted about 50 minutes. Below is a summary of the answers and some audio grabs via Twitter. No material protest votes. No sign of webcast archive so have requested.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2023 AUI hybrid AGM, held on October 18.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2023 Cochlear hybrid AGM held on October 17, along with a summary of the answers and some video highlights. See webcast of 91 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2023 IDP hybrid AGM held on October 17. The last question wasn't asked and some of the others were censored by the moderator. See webcast of 36 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 6 Stockland AGM questions lobbed at their hybrid gathering on October 16, 2023, along with a summary of some of the answers and some video links via Twitter.
Here are the 6 online questions lodged at the 2023 TWE hybrid AGM, held on October 16. They weren't asked in the end as I attended and this stuffed up the online questions. See webcast of AGM with key exchanges starting 83 minutes into proceedings. A big 47% protest vote against rem report. See AAP coverage of meeting.
Here is the text of 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 CBA AGM held on October 11, along with a summary of some of the answers and some video links. There were no material protest votes. See full video archive of webcast.
Here is the text of the 6 questions at the 2023 CSL hybrid AGM held on October 11, 2023, along with a summary of the answers. There was a 23% vote against the rem report and almost 25% against the CEO's LTI grant. See webcast of 59 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 IAG hybrid AGM held on October 11, along with some video grabs via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 10 questions asked at the 2023 Neuren Pharmaceuticals hybrid AGM held on May 30.
Here is the text of the 5 multi-pronged written questions asked at the 2023 Macquarie Group hybrid AGM held on July 27 which, to their credit, were all read out in full. Below is also a summary of the answers and some video footage via Twitter. The voting results weren't displayed until after the Q&A had finished and showed a 19.3% vote against the rem report.
Below is the text of the 10 written questions asked at the 1 hour 2023 Task Ltd hybrid AGM held in Auckland on July 24, along with Twitter videos of the various exchanges. See webcast of full meeting, the notice of meeting and voting results.
Here is the text of the 8 written questions asked at the 2023 29Metals hybrid AGM held on June 1, along with a summary of the answers and some videos grabs of the exchanges via Twitter. The only protest vote was 5% against the CEO's incentive grant.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 90 minute 2023 Atlas Arteria hybrid AGM held on May 30, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs of the exchanges.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2023 AFIC hybrid AGM held on October 3, along with some video grabs via Twitter. Two of them weren't asked, unfortunately.
Here is the text of 7 written questions lodged at the 2023 Fisher & Paykel hybrid AGM held on August 29. See archive copy of 87 minute webcast. No early disclosure of proxies in formal presos and only protest 17% against pay rise for NEDs.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions asked at the 2023 Xero virtual AGM held on August 17, plus a summary of the answers with video grabs via Twitter. Watch the 61 minute webcast archive.
Here is the text of the 10 online written questions lodged at the 2023 Invocare hybrid AGM held on May 26, only half of which were asked. The meeting lasted 126 minutes with plenty of takeover heat from the floor.
Here is the text of the 4 written questions asked at the 2023 Boart Longyear virtual AGM held on May 25.
Here is the text of the written questions submitted online during the 95 minute 2023 Telix Pharmaceuticals hybrid AGM held on May 24, along with a summary of the answers and some video grabs.
Here is the text of the 9 written questions asked online during the 2023 Ventia Services virtual AGM held on May 23, along with a summary of the answers and video grabs of the exchange via this high quality webcast and Twitter. Chair David Moffatt even said (watch video) he enjoyed the diverse range of questions at the end of the meeting.
Here is the text of the 9 written online questions asked during the 2023 Regal Funds Management hybrid AGM held on May 23. No webcast archive has been provided and all resolutions supported by more than 99% of voted stock.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 45 minute Pointsbet hybrid EGM held on June 30, 2023 to approve the $US225 million sale of its US business to rival Fanatics. Chair Brett Paton gave an informative EGM address and the vote was 99% in favour.
Here is the text of the 8 questions asked at the 40 minute 2023 Kina Securities virtual AGM held on June 9, plus a summary of the answers with some video grabs via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions asked at the 2023 Yancoal hybrid AGM held on May 31, and a summary of the answers with some audio grabs via Twitter.
Having attended the May 29 Alumina AGM in person, below are links to audio grabs of the various questions raised and answers provided. The biggest protest vote was 5.38% against chairman Peter Day.
Here is the text of the 6 written online questions asked at the 2023 Viva Energy hybrid AGM held on May 23. See webcast of 72 minute meeting, along with summary of answer and video grabs below.
QBE does not offer an AGM transcript so having attended in person in Sydney, the easiest way to capture the highlights of the 2023 hybrid AGM held on May 12 is to publish these video grabs from the webcast archive via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 11 questions lodged at the 2023 Waypoint REIT hybrid AGM held on May 18, along with a summary of the answers provided.
Here is the text of the 12 written questions lodged during the 2023 Here, There & Everywhere hybrid AGM, along with a summary of the answers.
See text of 8 written questions asked at the 2023 IRESS hybrid AGM held on May 4..
Here is the text of the two online written questions asked at the 2023 Rio Tinto Ltd hybrid AGM held on May 4 in Perth, along with videos of the responses.
Here is the text of the 12 written questions asked at the 2023 Iluka Resources hybrid AGM held on May 10, along with a summary of the answers provided. There was no censorship at what was a well run 110 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the questions asked at the NZ ME hybrid AGM held on April 26, 2023.
Here is the text of the 9 questions asked at the 2023 Pepper Money online AGM held on Thursday, April 27.
Here is the text of the 7 questions asked at the 2023 online only Bell Financial Group AGM held on April 19. Only three of them were asked during the 26 minute meeting and those exchanges are summarised below. The webcast archive was initially made available via the company's home page and have requested it be permanently published with its own URL.
Here is the text of the 13 questions asked at the 2023 AMP virtual AGM held on March 31. And kudos to AMP for publishing this archive of the nearly 4 hour webcast, along with this full transcript.
Here is the text of the 12 questions asked at the 2022 Betmakers hybrid AGM held on November 22, plus a summary of the answers. No webcast archive provided even though AGM debate generated ASX queries and media coverage.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at the 2022 Monadelphous hybrid AGM held on November 22. Not all were read out and the company emailed later to provide some clarifying answers. See webcast of 69 minute meeting.
Below is the text of the 10 written questions submitted at the 2022 Bluescope Steel hybrid AGM which was held in Wollongong on November 22. See video archive of 122 minute meeting.
Here is the text of 14 written questions submitted at the 2022 Pro Medicus hybrid AGM held on November 21, some of which weren't asked. See video archive of the 100 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 15 questions asked at the 2022 Hills Industries hybrid AGM on November 23 which lasted an hour. A summary of the responses is below. No webcast archive but emailed a request on January 16, 2023.
Here is the text of the 13 written questions asked at the 2022 Advanced Share Registries virtual AGM held on November 18. No AGM webcast initially provided so emailed a request on January 16, 2023 and got this link to the 49 minute meeting two days later.
Here is the text of the questions lodged at the 2022 Auswide Bank hybrid AGM held on November 23, along with a summary of some of the answers. Watch video archive of 66 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 13 questions lodged at the 2023 Technology One hybrid AGM held on February 22, which lasted for 68 minutes with only the ASA rep and I asking questions. There was a disappointing amount of censorship of the questions and chair Pat O'Sullivan was very brief in those he did answer.
Questions asked at 2022 Starpharma hybrid AGM, which was held on November 29 and lasted two hours and 20 minutes. The formal addresses dragged on for an hour and this archived AGM webcast only lasts 91 minutes so there appears to have been some editing down, potentially including some of these questions listed as "not asked" below.
Here is the text of 16 questions lodged at the Aristocrat Leisure AGM held on February 24, 2022. Aristocrat is still refusing to publish an archive of the 90 minute AGM webcast, which contributed to a decision to run for the board at the 2023 AGM. An extract from ASA's 2022 AGM report is included below as it has some details on the answers.
Here is the text of the 12 questions asked at the 2022 Goodman Group hybrid AGM held on November 17, plus a summary of the answers provided. See webcast archive of 100 minute meeting.
These 9 questions were submitted at the 2022 Collins Foods AGM held on Friday, September 2 but only 5 of them were actually asked. The meeting only lasted 61 minutes and we finally got both an audio archive and transcript 4 months after the meeting after engaging directly with chair Robert Kaye.
Here is the text of the 14 questions Stephen Mayne lodged at the 2022 Scentre Group AGM held on April 7, 2022 and check out this partial transcript demonstrating how chair Brian Schwartz butchered most of them.
Here is the text of the 7 questions asked at the 2022 Qube hybrid AGM held on November 24. See webcast of 83 minute meeting. Biggest protest vote was 5.4% against veteran chair Alan Davies.
Here is the text of the 7 questions asked at the 2022 Karoon Energy hybrid AGM held on November 24. Watch webcast of 98 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 15 questions asked at the 2022 Cromwell Property Group hybrid AGM held in Brisbane on November 16, along with a summary of some of the answers and some video grabs. Watch webcast archive.
Here is the text of the 8 written questions asked at the fully virtual 2022 Pact Group AGM held on November 16. Chair Raphael Geminder wasn't keen to talk about his controlling stake or intentions but see below for some answers sent by the company after the meeting. Listen to audio archive of 1 hour meeting.
Here is the text of the 16 questions asked at the 2022 Platinum Asset Management hybrid AGM held on November 16. Watch video archive of 2 hour and 22 minute AGM.
Here is the text of 12 questions asked at the 30 minute 2022 Opthea virtual meeting held on November 16. No sign of any webcast archive here.
Here is the text of the 10 written questions asked at the 2022 Capitol Health virtual AGM held on November 15, along with a summary of the answers and links to some audio via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 9 written questions asked at the 2022 Allkem hybrid AGM held on November 15. No one else asked questions. Watch webcast of 86 minute meeting.
These 7 written questions were lodged during the Sports Entertainment Group 2022 hybrid AGM held on November 9 but were all ignored despite a message from the company during the zoom meeting that the questions would be answered later in the meeting, which only lasted 23 minutes with no shareholder questions. Very disappointing. Watch video via twitter of chair Craig Coleman prematurely closing the meeting. Emailed requested access to webcast archive on January 18.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions lodged during the 2022 REA Group hybrid AGM held on November 10, plus a brief summary of any answers provided and links to some video grabs.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions asked at the 2022 Nine Entertainment hybrid AGM held on November 10, 7 of which were asked whilst 2 other topics were covered by other shareholders.
Here is the text of the 12 questions asked at the 2022 Monash IVF hybrid AGM which was held on November 11. No one else asked question even though they have about 7,000 shareholders.
Here is the text of the 7 written Accent Group questions lodged at the 2022 hybrid AGM held on November 11.
11 questions asked at Alterity Therapeutics 2022 hybrid AGM held on November 11.
Here is the text of the 8 questions asked at the 2022 Liberty Financial Group hybrid AGM held on November 9, plus a summary of the answers provided.
Here is the text of the 4 questions lodged at the 2022 Coles hybrid AGM held on November 9, plus a summary of the responses by old school chair James Graham, along with video grabs via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 10 written questions lodged at the 2022 Newcrest hybrid AGM held on November 9.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions lodged at the 2022 Sims Group hybrid AGM held on November 8 plus a brief summary of the answers. Only two weren't asked.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions asked at the 2022 Spark NZ hybrid AGM held on November 4.
Here is the text of the 8 questions lodged at the 2022 Qantas hybrid AGM held on November 4, with a brief summary of the answers and links to a couple of videos. Two were ignored and only 4 were read out in full unedited. See webcast archive of 128 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 8 questions asked at the 2022 Bendigo Bank hybrid AGM held on Monday, November 7.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2022 Servcorp hybrid AGM held at 4.30pm on November 9 in Sydney.
Here is the text of the 12 written questions lodged at the 2022 ZIP AGM which was a fully virtual meeting held on November 3.
Here is the text of 10 written questions lodged at the 2022 Polynovo hybrid AGM held on October 28. The majority, which are italicised, were censored and not asked.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions asked at the 2022 Domino's hybrid AGM held on November 2, plus a brief summary of the answers provided.
Here is the text of the 5 written questions lodged at the 2022 Southern Cross Media hybrid AGM held on October 21. All answers were provided by CEO Grant Blackley and no other shareholders asked questions.
Here is the text of the 15 questions asked at the 2022 Globe International virtual AGM and subsequent spill meeting held on October 27, plus a summary of the answers given.
Here is the text of the 12 written questions lodged at the 2022 Data3 hybrid AGM held on October 27, plus a brief summary of the answers. Only the last 2 weren't asked.
Here is the text of the 3 written questions lodged at the 2022 Wesfarmers hybrid AGM held on October 27.
Here is the text of the 9 questions asked at 2022 GUD hybrid AGM held on October 27.
Here is the text of the 6 written questions lodged at JB Hi Fi 2022 hybrid AGM, held on October 27.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the 2022 IAG hybrid AGM which was held on October 21. Watch webcast of 106 minute meeting including this 2 minute video of the fire alarms interruption.
Here is the text of 7 written questions submitted at the 2022 Magellan Financial Group hybrid AGM held on Thursday, October 20.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at 2022 St Barbara Mines hybrid AGM held on October 26.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions lodged during the 2022 Dexus hybrid AGM held on October 26, along with a brief summary of the answers with links to some short videos taken on the Iphone from the webcast and published via Twitter.
Here is the text of the 10 written questions lodged during the 2022 Tabcorp hybrid AGM held on October 26.
Here is the text of the 9 questions and comments lodged at the 2022 Regis Healthcare hybrid AGM held on October 25, 7 of which were read out.
Here is the the text of the 5 questions asked at the 2022 Diversified United Investment (DUI) hybrid AGM held on Thursday, October 20.
Here is the text of the 7 written questions lodged at the 2022 Perpetual hybrid AGM held on Thursday, October 20, plus a brief summary of the answers. Watch webcast archive of 2 hour and 42 minute meeting.
Here are the written questions lobbed at the 2022 Transurban AGM which started at 11am on October 20.
Here is the text of 13 written questions lodged at the 2022 APA AGM held on October 19, with only 3 not being asked after the chairman called time citing a 2 question limit per resolution.
Here is the text of the 12 written questions lodged at the 2022 Endeavour Group AGM held on August 18, all but one of which were asked, although chair Peter Hearl didn't allow any other director to answer any of them.
Here is the text of the 9 questions asked at the 2022 Healthia hybrid AGM held on November 29 in Brisbane. No sign of any webcast archive so don't know what the answers were.
Here is the text of the 10 written questions asked at the 2022 hybrid Cochlear AGM, along with a summary of the response. All questions were read out in full, which is to Cochlear's credit.
6 written questions asked at Telstra's 2022 EGM approving an internal restructure, which was held on October 11 half an hour after the AGM.
Here is the text of the 6 online questions lodged at the 2022 Telstra AGM held on October 11.
Here is the text of the 10 questions asked at the 2022 Appen AGM held on May 27, 2022. The italicised bit weren't read out.
Here is a summary of the 10 questions asked at the 2022 AMCIL AGM held on October 4, plus links to the webcast archive.
See text of 11 questions asked at Eagers Automotive AGM held on May 19. 2022
Here is the text of the 8 written questions lodged and asked at the 32 minute Crown Resorts scheme meeting held on May 20, 2022. A brief summary of the answers from chair Ziggy Switkowski is also provided.
Below is the text of written questions lodged at the 2022 Woodside Energy AGM held on May 19 in Perth. All were read out in full with the exception of the final one.
The following 6 online questions were asked at the 2022 AFIC AGM held in Melbourne on October 4.
Here is the text of the 14 written online questions asked by Stephen Mayne at the 2022 ASX AGM held on September 28. Moderator Matthew Gibbs never disclosed who was asking the questions but he read all of them out with only the odd edit. Here is the web page with access to both the transcript and AGM webcast.
These 10 written questions were lodged at the 2022 Suncorp AGM, which was held on September 23, a day later than originally planned due to the public holiday for the Queen. Watch high quality webcast of meeting which lasted 2 hours and 26 minutes. The floor debate started after 67 minutes and 7 or our questions were dealt with.
Here is the text of 14 live written questions lodged during today's Air New Zealand AGM, although those in italics below were not read out even though announcer/moderator "Kim" said on multiple occasions "there are not further questions online", which was false. Disappointing to only have 4 questions read out.
The following 15 written questions were asked at the hybrid Webjet AGM held on August 31, 2022 and only question 14 was not asked. See full transcript. Unless detailed, all answers were by chair Roger Sharp.
Text of 11 questions submitted at 2022 Dicker Data AGM held on May 20, 2022. There was some abbreviating in the reading.
Online written questions lodged by Stephen Mayne at the 2022 OzForex AGM, held on August 11, 2022. Only 4 of the 14 were dealt with. The 10 which were ignored are in italics. Watch the full webcast on Youtube.
Here is the full text of all 12 written questions lodged at the ALS AGM held on August 23, the majority of which were ignored. See voting results with 2 big protest votes against both directors up for election.
The Macquarie Group 2022 AGM saw 14 questions lodged by Stephen Mayne and his father David Mayne, across 3 different platforms - through Link before the AGM, via Lumi during the AGM and in person at the physical AGM. Here is a full transcript of all exchanges.
Here is the text of the 6 questions asked at the Eagers Automotive EGM held on July 15 2022 to approve the $193 million related party transaction to purchase the ACT car dealership assets off Nick Politis, a director of Eagers and the largest shareholder with almost 28%. They were read out in full with comprehensive answers provided.
Below is the text of the 9 questions lodged at the 2022 Costa Group AGM. I wasn't able to listen and they haven't provided a webcast archive so at this point I don't know what happened.
The following online written questions were asked by Stephen Mayne at the 2022 CIMIC AGM held on April 6. Watch the webcast.
Text of 7 questions asked at 2022 QBE AGM held on May 5, with a brief summary of the answers provided. All questions were read out in full without editing. Watch the full webcast archive, but no transcript provided.
Questions asked at 2022 IRESS AGM held on May 5.
The following 8 text questions were lodged ahead of the 2022 TPG Telecom AGM held on May 3.
Below is the text of 11 questions asked at the 2022 Santos AGM held on May 3, along with the 4 which weren't read out. See webcast archive of 3 hour and 28 minute meeting.
Here is the text of the 5 text questions asked at the 2022 Iluka Resources AGM which were all read out in full and addressed by chairman Greg Martin. I miscalculated the time difference with WA so logged into the AGM when it was almost finished after 50 minutes of action.
GQG Partners is a Florida-based fund manager which currently manages $US92 billion and raised $1.18 billion selling 20% of its stock in Australia last year. Stephen Mayne was the sole inquisitor at its inaugural AGM on April 27 and this is how it rolled.
Here is the text of eight questions lodged at the 2022 Latitude Financial Group AGM, many of which were butchered by chairman Mike Tilley who insisted on reading them out himself, despite being asked not to.
There are the written questions lodged by Stephen Mayne at the Endeavour Group AGM held on October 21. Those that were ignored have been italicised.
This story appeared in Crikey after the News Corp 2020 online AGM and below it are the 8 questions which were submitted, only two of which were asked. Click here to listen to the pathetically short 26 minute AGM webcast, where shareholder free speech was suppressed as usual.
The following 3 questions were lodged at the Ausnet takeover meeting held on January 28, 2022. The first was ignored but the other two were duly read out and answered.
Below is the text of the 7 text questions asked at the Sydney Airport takeover meeting held on February 3, 2022, all of which were duly read out in full, albeit sometimes broken up into separate missives. When the transcript arrives we'll have a fuller account of the answers.
Here is an edited transcript of the exchanges from last Thursday's Macquarie Group AGM in Sydney.
Is Jeffrey Browne suitable to become Collingwood President? He is the current chair of ASX-listed Moelis Australia and below is a case study looking at how Moelis Australia handled the 22 online written questions which Stephen Mayne lodged during its May 28 AGM. Only 5 of them weren't asked. The company refuses to publish an archive of the AGM webcast, which is poor transparency.
Here is the text of the 11 written questions lodged during the Rio Tinto AGM. Only two of them were asked in a package linked in with two other shareholders.
In 2010 we put together this package of companies where we have had more than three encounters over the years. News Corp and Macquarie are equal favorites with eight AGMs attended.
Here are the lists of the AGMs we've attended since 1998.
The triumphant update sent out a few hours after the News Corp AGM.
Here is an edited transcript of the two Westfield meetings held in 2014 when the proposed controversial restructure was eventually deferred after looking like being headed for a narrow defeat.
This list tracks the voting results from the 233 June 30 balance date companies which held their AGM on the last possible day, November 28, 2014.
With the world's biggest small portfolio and the luxury of our own publication, there is no problem speaking at AGMs these days. However, as a regular reporter for mainstream newspapers and someone who was almost financially ruined there were plenty of meetings over the years which I attended but didn't ask questions at. Here is a list of them, along with any relevent reports from the day.
This article appeared in the Chartered Secretaries Australia magazine in 2006.
The 2021 AGM mini season was unique because it was a combination of physical, online only and hybrid AGMs. Here is what happened, including whether companies have made a full archive of the meeting available.
This was first published by Crikey in 2000, but has resonance today as we strive to improve public company AGMs.
Shareholder activism, and journalism for that matter, is all about trying to change outcomes for the better and this tale is one of the Mayne Report's proudest boasts, because it really does seem that we helped save the shareholders of Insurance Australia Group $300 million.
Listed Australian asset manager HFA Holdings has agreed to pay $730 million for a US hedge fund called Lighthouse Partners such that the combined operation will look after $9 billion globally.
The ding dong struggle between Robert Reeves and his former colleagues at the ANZ bank continues.
This is the report sent to Mayne Report subscribers hours after the Timbercorp AGM finished on February 21, 2008.
This account of the Channel Ten AGM was sent to Crikey subscribers on December 5, 2001.
We're getting towards the end of our exercise in writing to companies asking for transcripts or audio files from old AGMs, so that a future book project will accurately tell the tale of what happened at some 600-plus AGMs over the years. Here's a progress report thus far:
Incumbent directors in Australia average around 96% of votes when they are up for re-election. Here is a slightly dated list of directors who received a protest vote exceeding 10%.
The Woolworths AGM on November 16 in Sydney was a good opportunity to put the retailing powerhouse through its paces about pokies, succession planning and even the forthcoming Rudd Government's prices inquiry. But first, look at this disgraceful picture from one of my local pubs.
We gave Gunns plenty of stick at their AGM in Launceston on Thursday as you can see from this piece sent to Mayne Report subscribers early on Friday morning.
Taking on Westfield boss Frank Lowy in 1999 produced this account for www.jeffed.com.
Stephen Mayne took on John Singleton at his AGM in May 2001 and this is what was sent to Crikey subscribers at the time.
Copyright © 2024 The Mayne Report. All rights reserved